PM 05-24-2025 Is One Church as Good As Another?

Last updated: June 6, 2026

Share This Page Copy, email, or post the link
Facebook Email
← Back to Library

PM 05-24-2025 Is One Church as Good As Another?

Learning Objectives

TextMatthew 16:18
SeriesSermons 2001 Rewritten
Date
SpeakerEd Rangel
LocationWaupaca Church of Christ
Bible VersionNASB 1995
Sermon TypeExpository
1.

Identify the central Bible doctrine taught in the sermon text.

2.

Explain the main warnings, promises, or responsibilities found in the passage.

3.

Apply the lesson to personal faith, obedience, worship, and service.

4.

Defend the truth of the passage against careless, worldly, or denominational thinking.

5.

Call hearers to obey God faithfully and remain steadfast in Christ.

Occasion: Sermon Outline

Thesis

SpeakerEd Rangel
Bible VersionNASB 1995

One church is not as good as another unless it is the church Christ built, submits to the authority of Christ, teaches the doctrine of Christ, worships by the authority of Christ, and does the will of the Father.

Hook / Opening

People say it all the time: “It does not really matter what church you go to.”

That sounds kind. It sounds tolerant. It sounds broad-minded. But here is the problem: Jesus never said it.

Jesus did not say, “I will build many churches.” He did not say, “Choose the one that fits your taste.” He did not say, “As long as people are sincere, every religious body is acceptable.”

Jesus said, “I will build My church” (Matthew 16:18).

That one word settles the matter: My.

The church belongs to Christ. If it belongs to Christ, then man does not get to redesign it, rename it, reorganize it, or worship in it however he pleases.

The real question is not, “Is one church as good as another?”

The real question is, “Which church did Christ build?”

Objectives

I.

Show that the question must be answered by the authority of Christ, not by human opinion.

II.

Explain that Jesus taught a narrow way, even for sincere religious people.

III.

Prove from Scripture that Christ built one church, His one body.

IV.

Urge every hearer to pursue the church Christ built by comparing belief, worship, organization, and practice with the New Testament pattern.

Introduction.

I.

This question is too important to answer with feelings.

A.

Many people answer it by family history.

1.

“My parents went there.”

a.

Family loyalty may explain attachment, but it does not establish authority.

2.

“My grandparents helped build that church.”

a.

A building built by family is not the same as the church built by Christ.

B.

Many people answer it by personal preference.

1.

“I like the preacher.”

a.

A likable preacher is not the standard.

2.

“I like the worship.”

a.

Enjoyment is not the same as authorization.

3.

“I feel comfortable there.”

a.

Comfort is not the same as truth.

II.

This question must be answered by Scripture.

A.

Jesus has all authority.

1.

Matthew 28:18 says, “All authority has been given to Me in heaven and on earth.”

a.

If Jesus has all authority, then no religious body has authority to change His word.

B.

Jesus’ word will judge us.

2.

John 12:48 says the word Jesus spoke will judge men at the last day.

a.

Judgment will not be based on what sounded generous to men.

b.

Judgment will be based on the word of Christ.

C.

Scripture equips completely.

3.

Second Timothy 3:16–17 teaches that Scripture equips the man of God for every good work.

a.

If Scripture equips completely, then the church does not need human additions to become acceptable.

I. The Answer Must Be Authoritative, Not Personal.

I.

Man’s opinion cannot settle the question.

A.

A preacher’s opinion cannot save anyone.

1.

My preference is not the standard.

a.

A preacher has no authority unless he is speaking the word of God.

2.

My background is not the standard.

a.

A man can inherit religious error from sincere people.

B.

A religious leader can be wrong.

1.

A sincere preacher can be wrong.

a.

Sincerity does not turn error into truth.

2.

A popular preacher can be wrong.

a.

A crowd does not prove divine approval.

3.

A kind preacher can be wrong.

a.

Kindness does not authorize false doctrine.

II.

Christ alone has the authority to answer.

A.

Matthew 28:18 gives Christ total authority.

1.

“All authority” leaves no room for man-made doctrine.

a.

No creed has authority over Christ.

b.

No council has authority over Christ.

c.

No denomination has authority over Christ.

B.

John 12:48 gives Christ the final word in judgment.

2.

His word will judge us.

a.

Not our assumptions.

b.

Not our feelings.

c.

Not our traditions.

C.

Second Timothy 3:16–17 gives Scripture complete sufficiency.

3.

Scripture teaches.

a.

The church must learn from God.

4.

Scripture reproves.

a.

The church must let God expose error.

5.

Scripture corrects.

a.

The church must let God fix what man has broken.

6.

Scripture trains in righteousness.

a.

The church must be shaped by revelation, not religious fashion.

III.

The first question is not, “Which church do I like?”

A.

The first question is, “Which church did Christ build?”

1.

Matthew 16:18 says, “I will build My church.”

a.

Christ is the builder.

b.

Christ is the owner.

c.

Christ is the authority.

B.

The second question is, “Does this church follow His word?”

2.

If it teaches what Christ did not authorize, it has moved beyond Christ.

a.

Moving beyond Christ is not spiritual progress.

b.

Moving beyond Christ is rebellion.

II. Jesus Taught a Narrow Way.

I.

The world hates narrowness.

A.

Modern culture treats religion like personal taste.

1.

One person chooses one church.

a.

Another person chooses another church.

2.

Then people say, “As long as everyone is sincere, it is all fine.”

a.

That sounds modern.

b.

It does not sound like Jesus.

B.

Jesus did not teach that all religious roads lead to life.

1.

He did not teach that all sincere people are saved.

a.

Sincerity must submit to truth.

2.

He did not teach that all religious activity is acceptable.

a.

Religious action without divine authority is still lawlessness.

II.

Matthew 7:13–14 teaches that the way to life is narrow.

A.

Jesus said the broad way leads to destruction.

1.

Many enter through it.

a.

Majority religion is not automatically safe.

b.

Popularity is not proof of truth.

B.

Jesus said the narrow way leads to life.

2.

Few find it.

a.

That is not harsh preacher language.

b.

That is the language of Christ.

C.

No man has the right to widen what Jesus narrowed.

3.

We may want to make the way broader.

a.

But compassion without truth is not love.

4.

We may want to make people comfortable.

a.

But comfort does not save the soul.

III.

Matthew 7:21–23 teaches that not all religious people are saved.

A.

Jesus says not everyone who says, “Lord, Lord,” will enter the kingdom.

1.

These people were religious.

a.

They used the language of faith.

2.

These people were active.

a.

They claimed mighty works.

3.

These people were surprised.

a.

Surprise at judgment will not change the verdict.

B.

Jesus says the one who does the will of the Father will enter.

4.

The issue is obedience.

a.

Not religious vocabulary.

b.

Not emotional sincerity.

c.

Not spiritual busyness.

C.

Jesus identifies the problem as lawlessness.

5.

Lawlessness includes doing religious things without God’s authority.

a.

A church can use the name of Jesus while practicing what Jesus never authorized.

b.

A person can call Jesus Lord while refusing the will of the Father.

III. Jesus Built One Church.

I.

Matthew 16:18 must be allowed to speak plainly.

A.

Jesus said, “I will build My church.”

1.

“I” identifies the builder.

a.

Christ built the church.

2.

“My” identifies the owner.

a.

The church belongs to Christ.

3.

“Church” is singular.

a.

Jesus did not promise to build competing religious bodies.

B.

Christ is not the author of contradiction.

4.

He did not build one church teaching baptism is necessary and another teaching baptism is optional.

a.

The apostles preached baptism for the forgiveness of sins (Acts 2:38).

5.

He did not build one church worshiping one way and another church worshiping another way by human invention.

a.

Worship must be governed by divine authority.

6.

He did not build one church under His headship and another under denominational machinery.

a.

Christ is the head of the church.

II.

Ephesians 1:22–23 identifies the church as Christ’s body.

A.

God put all things under Christ’s feet.

1.

Christ is head over all things to the church.

a.

The church does not rule Christ.

b.

Christ rules the church.

B.

The church is His body.

2.

The body submits to the head.

a.

The head directs.

b.

The body obeys.

III.

Ephesians 4:4 says there is one body.

A.

If the body is the church, and there is one body, then there is one church.

1.

That is not hard to understand.

a.

It only becomes hard when men try to defend division.

B.

Denominationalism contradicts the one-body teaching of Scripture.

2.

Denominationalism says many bodies are acceptable.

a.

Scripture says there is one body.

3.

Denominationalism says contradictory doctrines can all belong to Christ.

a.

Scripture says there is one faith.

IV.

First Corinthians 1:10 condemns religious division.

A.

Paul pleaded that brethren speak the same thing.

1.

He commanded that there be no divisions among them.

a.

Division is not harmless.

b.

Division is not spiritual maturity.

B.

Paul called them to be made complete in the same mind and same judgment.

2.

That does not fit the idea that one church is as good as another.

a.

Paul did not bless religious division.

b.

Paul rebuked it.

IV. We Must Pursue the Church Christ Built.

I.

God has often provided one authorized place of safety.

A.

In the flood, safety was in the ark.

1.

Genesis 7 shows one ark, not many.

a.

Those inside were saved.

b.

Those outside were lost.

B.

In the Passover, safety was under the blood.

2.

Exodus 12 shows one authorized way of deliverance.

a.

Sincerity without the blood would not have saved the firstborn.

C.

In Jericho, safety was in Rahab’s house.

3.

Joshua 2 shows one marked house of safety.

a.

Those inside were spared.

b.

Those outside were not.

D.

In Christ, salvation is in His body.

4.

Acts 2:47 says the Lord added to their number those who were being saved.

a.

The saved were not left to join religious bodies of their choice.

b.

The Lord added them to His people.

II.

Matthew 15:13 warns against religious plants God did not plant.

A.

Jesus said every plant His heavenly Father did not plant shall be uprooted.

1.

That is a serious warning.

a.

If God did not plant it, it will not stand.

b.

If Christ did not build it, it cannot claim His ownership.

III.

Hebrews 11:6 teaches diligent pursuit.

A.

God rewards those who seek Him.

1.

Not those who casually accept inherited religion.

a.

Inherited religion must be tested.

2.

Not those who defend tradition over Scripture.

a.

Tradition must bow to revelation.

3.

Not those who refuse to examine what they practice.

a.

Careless religion is dangerous.

IV.

The marks of identification must be tested by the New Testament.

A.

What did the New Testament church believe?

1.

It believed Jesus is the Christ, the Son of God.

a.

Faith was rooted in the identity and authority of Christ.

2.

It preached the death, burial, and resurrection of Christ.

a.

The gospel was not moralism or entertainment.

3.

It taught repentance and baptism for the forgiveness of sins.

a.

Acts 2:38 gives the apostolic answer.

B.

How did the New Testament church worship?

4.

It continued in the apostles’ teaching.

a.

Doctrine mattered.

5.

It broke bread on the first day of the week.

a.

Acts 20:7 shows the disciples gathered to break bread.

6.

It prayed, sang, gave, and worshiped by divine authority.

a.

Worship is not ours to invent.

C.

How was the New Testament church organized?

7.

Local congregations had elders and deacons.

a.

The organization was local, not denominational.

8.

Christ was the head.

a.

No earthly headquarters has the right to replace His rule.

D.

What did the New Testament church belong to?

9.

It belonged to Christ.

a.

It did not rally around human founders.

b.

It did not wear man-made identities.

c.

It stood under the authority of the Lord.

Conclusion.

1.

The question is not, “Is one church as good as another?”

a.

That question starts in the wrong place.

b.

It assumes man has the right to compare churches by preference.

c.

The real question is, “Which church did Christ build?”

2.

Jesus gave the answer.

a.

He said, “I will build My church.”

b.

He is the builder.

c.

He is the owner.

d.

He is the head.

e.

He is the authority.

3.

The way is narrow.

a.

Not everyone who says, “Lord, Lord,” will enter the kingdom.

b.

Religious activity without the will of God is lawlessness.

c.

The one who enters is the one who does the will of the Father.

4.

The church is one body.

a.

Ephesians 4:4 says there is one body.

b.

The body is the church.

c.

Christ is not divided.

d.

His church must not be reduced to one choice among many.

5.

If we believe what the first Christians believed and do what they did, we will be what they were.

a.

Not a denomination.

b.

Not a man-made religious body.

c.

Not a church built on tradition.

d.

Christians belonging to the church Christ built.

Invitation.

1.

Hear the word.

a.

Romans 10:17 says faith comes from hearing, and hearing by the word of Christ.

2.

Believe Christ.

a.

John 8:24 warns that unless you believe that Jesus is He, you will die in your sins.

3.

Repent.

a.

Acts 17:30 says God commands all people everywhere to repent.

4.

Confess Christ.

a.

Romans 10:9–10 teaches confession with the mouth and belief in the heart.

5.

Be baptized for the remission of sins.

a.

Acts 2:38 commands repentance and baptism in the name of Jesus Christ for the forgiveness of sins.

6.

Live faithfully.

a.

Revelation 2:10 calls the Christian to be faithful until death.

Application.

1.

Apply the doctrine personally.

a.

Do not leave the lesson as information only.

b.

Let the word of God examine your heart, conduct, and priorities.

c.

Obedience begins when the hearer stops excusing himself.

2.

Apply the doctrine congregationally.

a.

The church must be shaped by Scripture.

b.

Brethren must encourage one another to remain faithful.

c.

A congregation is strengthened when truth is taught and practiced.

3.

Apply the doctrine evangelistically.

a.

Souls need the gospel.

b.

The lost must be taught plainly and lovingly.

c.

The faithful must not be ashamed of the Lord’s way.

Word Study.

WordOriginalMeaningUse in Text
Worshipπροσκυνέω / proskyneōTo bow before, reverence, or offer homage.Frames worship as submission to God rather than self-expression.
Singᾄδω / adōTo sing praise.Identifies the vocal action God authorizes in New Testament worship.
Doctrineδιδαχή / didachēTeaching, instruction.Shows worship must be governed by apostolic teaching.
Heartκαρδία / kardiaInner person, mind, will, and affection.Locates true worship in reverent inward submission.
Truthἀλήθεια / alētheiaTruth, reality, what is revealed by God.Keeps worship tied to revelation rather than preference.
Obedienceὑπακοή / hypakoēSubmissive hearing, obedience.Connects hearing God’s word with doing what He commands.

|---|---|---|---| | Worship | προσκυνέω / proskyneō | To bow before, reverence, or offer homage. | Frames worship as submission to God rather than self-expression. | | Sing | ᾄδω / adō | To sing praise. | Identifies the vocal action God authorizes in New Testament worship. | | Doctrine | διδαχή / didachē | Teaching, instruction. | Shows worship must be governed by apostolic teaching. | | Heart | καρδία / kardia | Inner person, mind, will, and affection. | Locates true worship in reverent inward submission. | | Truth | ἀλήθεια / alētheia | Truth, reality, what is revealed by God. | Keeps worship tied to revelation rather than preference. | | Obedience | ὑπακοή / hypakoē | Submissive hearing, obedience. | Connects hearing God’s word with doing what He commands. |

Scripture Interlock Table.

TestamentReferenceOriginal ContextConnection to Main TextDoctrinal UseSermon / Teaching Use
Old TestamentGenesis 1:1God is revealed as Creator.Establishes God’s authority over man.Shows that man answers to God.Useful for grounding the lesson in divine authority.
Old TestamentPsalm 119:105God’s word guides His people.Shows Scripture as the rule of faith and conduct.Supports Bible-based application.Useful for calling hearers back to the word.
Old TestamentEcclesiastes 12:13–14Man’s whole duty is to fear God and keep His commandments.Connects obedience with final accountability.Supports the need to obey God.Useful in conclusion and invitation.
New TestamentMatthew 7:21–23Jesus warns that not all religious people will enter the kingdom.Shows the need to do the Father’s will.Refutes empty profession.Useful for pressing obedience.
New TestamentRomans 10:17Faith comes by hearing the word of Christ.Shows how saving faith begins.Supports the invitation.Useful for gospel response.
New TestamentActs 2:38Peter commands repentance and baptism for forgiveness of sins.Shows the apostolic answer to convicted sinners.Supports baptism for remission of sins.Useful in invitation.
New TestamentRevelation 2:10Christians are called to be faithful until death.Shows the need for endurance.Supports faithful Christian living.Useful for closing exhortation.

|---|---|---|---|---|---| | Old Testament | Genesis 1:1 | God is revealed as Creator. | Establishes God’s authority over man. | Shows that man answers to God. | Useful for grounding the lesson in divine authority. | | Old Testament | Psalm 119:105 | God’s word guides His people. | Shows Scripture as the rule of faith and conduct. | Supports Bible-based application. | Useful for calling hearers back to the word. | | Old Testament | Ecclesiastes 12:13–14 | Man’s whole duty is to fear God and keep His commandments. | Connects obedience with final accountability. | Supports the need to obey God. | Useful in conclusion and invitation. | | New Testament | Matthew 7:21–23 | Jesus warns that not all religious people will enter the kingdom. | Shows the need to do the Father’s will. | Refutes empty profession. | Useful for pressing obedience. | | New Testament | Romans 10:17 | Faith comes by hearing the word of Christ. | Shows how saving faith begins. | Supports the invitation. | Useful for gospel response. | | New Testament | Acts 2:38 | Peter commands repentance and baptism for forgiveness of sins. | Shows the apostolic answer to convicted sinners. | Supports baptism for remission of sins. | Useful in invitation. | | New Testament | Revelation 2:10 | Christians are called to be faithful until death. | Shows the need for endurance. | Supports faithful Christian living. | Useful for closing exhortation. |

Ed Rangel

Author

Ed Rangel

Ed Rangel is a gospel preacher and Bible teacher. His work focuses on plain Scripture, biblical authority, the gospel of Christ, and faithful Christian living.

More teachings from Ed Rangel
Ask a Question About This Page Send a question, correction, or study request

Question or Comment

Ask a Question About This Page

If this raised a Bible question, send it here. Keep it honest, direct, and tied to the subject.